BY KELLY BESWICK

There are restaurants that promise something a little different, and then there is Island. The brainchild of Michelin-starred chefs Tom Brown and Brad Carter, this is surf and turf with a thoroughly modern twist, where exceptional British produce, imaginative cooking and a generous helping of culinary adventure combine to delicious effect.

We visited on a chilly November evening, when darkness had already fallen and there was a definite nip in the air. Happily, the George and Dragon on St John Street proved just the place to escape the cold. A handsome Grade II-listed Victorian boozer, built in 1889, it was formerly known as The Peasant before reclaiming its original George and Dragon name when it reopened in September 2026.

Downstairs, this is a proper old-school pub, with a wonderfully warm and friendly atmosphere. Busy and buzzing with after-work imbibers, it was exactly the sort of place where you could happily while away an hour over a drink. Indeed, I rather enjoyed doing just that while waiting for my dining companion to arrive.
Island has occupied the first floor since reopening, having relocated from its original King’s Cross home at Mare Street Market. Having Tom Brown and Brad Carter behind the venture was always going to make for an exciting partnership. Tom earned his first Michelin star at Hackney’s Cornerstone before returning to The Capital in Knightsbridge, where he has since won another, while Brad made his name at Birmingham’s acclaimed Carters of Moseley, which secured a Michelin star in 2015. With pedigree like that, expectations were running high before we’d even ascended the stairs.

And what a lovely surprise awaited us. Upstairs, the 60-cover dining room is a twinkly, welcoming wonderland, with something of a Dickensian feel. Large windows, sparkling crystal chandeliers and contemporary artwork on the walls combine to create a space that manages to feel both elegant and wonderfully relaxed. Diners steadily streamed in throughout our meal and, quite tellingly, not a single table remained empty during our stay.
Now, to those of a certain age, the words ‘surf and turf’ may conjure up memories of a Berni Inn or Beefeater, where an overcooked hunk of sirloin arrived accompanied by breaded scampi or a few prawns on top. Considered terribly exotic at the time, perhaps, but hardly a culinary revelation. Well, banish all thoughts of that 80s and 90s classic. Tom and Brad have taken the concept somewhere altogether more exciting, drawing inspiration from our rugged little island and its extraordinary natural larder. Their cooking brings land and sea together in a celebration of the very best British produce.
We were seated by a charming young server, who offered us a glass of English fizz while we perused the menu, which is relatively short and refreshingly unfussy, as all the best menus tend to be.

To start, we ordered a combination of Jungle Mignonette and Buffalo Oysters. The former, freshly shucked and topped with a sharp, punchy house mignonette, was beautifully balanced, cutting through the richness of the shellfish. But it was the Buffalo Oysters that had me in raptures. Bread crumbed, fried and smothered in a spicy, tangy buffalo-style dressing, finished with ranch sauce, they were quite simply sensational. Honestly, I could happily have polished off a dozen.

For our next course, I opted for Steak Tartare with Prawn Crackers, while my companion chose the Lamb Belly and Clam Skewer. The pared-back menu descriptions hardly do these dishes justice. My tartare was unlike any I’d tasted before, wonderfully rich and unctuous, with a depth of flavour that spoke of exceptionally good beef. The crisp prawn crackers were perfect for scooping up every last morsel. Meanwhile, my friend was clearly delighted with her skewer, where fatty, melt-in-the-mouth lamb alternated with smooth, salty clams, all brought together by an Asian-inspired glaze.

For the main event, we decided to share the Chop Board, very much one of Island’s signature offerings. And what a triumph it was. An incredible rib eye, cooked to perfection, boasted beautiful marbling and that wonderfully rich, beefy flavour you only get from a really good cut. Alongside it came a buttery, luxurious piece of monkfish, charred on the grill. Its dense, meaty white flesh had a remarkably lobster-like quality, making it the perfect seafood counterpart to the steak.

We chose crab sauce and green sauce to accompany our board, both of which were excellent. And because no feast is complete without a few sides, we added French Fries, dusted with seafood seasoning and served with a fantastically punchy aioli, and a generous heap of Chicken Oyster Caesar Salad. Replacing the traditional anchovy element with oyster was a clever touch, while a generous snowfall of grated Parmesan made it all the more irresistible. Different, delicious and a lovely example of the kitchen’s willingness to rethink familiar favourites.
Our knowledgeable server suggested a light, fruity bottle of red to complement our choices and, let’s just say, she knew exactly what she was talking about. It’s always a pleasure when staff genuinely understand the food and can guide you towards something that enhances the whole experience.

By this stage, I was beginning to think Island might just have secured itself a place in my personal restaurant hall of fame. But there was still time for a little something sweet. I opted for a comforting Irish coffee, which made a wonderfully warming end to the evening, while my companion couldn’t resist the Banoffee Pie, accompanied by the suggested tot of Caribbean rum. A handsome, sophisticated take on a familiar classic, it delivered on every level.
All in all, this was a meal that genuinely ranks among my top ten dining experiences. Island has managed to take a concept that could so easily have felt gimmicky and turn it into something rather special. The cooking is imaginative without being overcomplicated, the ingredients are allowed to shine, and the whole experience is underpinned by genuinely warm hospitality.
The combination of a characterful old pub downstairs and an accomplished, lively restaurant upstairs makes for a particularly appealing destination, whether you’re planning a special evening out or simply fancy treating yourself to something a little different.
Would I return? Most definitely. In fact, I’m already thinking about when I can next make it back. Island is a little gem in the heart of Clerkenwell, and I really couldn’t recommend it more highly.
Island, Surf & Turf
George and Dragon, 240 St John Street, London EC1V 4PH

